"It is not terribly rigid and cannot be manipulated very efficiently," said Kari Benson, a professor of biology at Lynchburg College. "It is not useful as a weapon. It is only used as a visual signal in a fight."
Benson, who co-authored the first paper with Alexandra Basolo, also a Lynchburg professor, explained to Discovery News, "The sword might signal many things: how strong and vigorous he is, how well he ate while growing up or simply by indicating that he is large."
The researchers staged duels between swordtails,
Xiphophorus helleri, by putting two comparably sized males with different-sized swords in a tank and then observing their interactions, which usually involved aggressive behavior, such as chasing and biting.
The researchers then artificially manipulated sword size by affixing fake plastic swords to the fish.
Repeatedly, the male with the bigger sword won. Often all he had to do was to show his sword and then the other male slunk away.