"We were quite surprised to find this subtle effect," said marine ecologist Peter Mumby of the University of Exeter in the U.K. It's a great example of how important it is to study actual reef ecology and not rely to heavily on fisheries models, he said.
"Until you actually study (reefs), you can't predict the effects," Mumby said. He and several colleagues published a report on the discovery in the Jan. 6 issue of the journal
Science.
Caribbean coral reefs have been in trouble for at least 20 years — ever since an unknown disease wiped out sea urchins that used to help keep the seaweed under control, said Mumby.
The only effective seaweed grazers that remain on the reefs are several species of parrotfish, he said.
When fishing was banned in a Bahamas marine reserve and the parrotfish-dining Nassau groupers bounced back, it wasn't expected to have a positive effect on the reefs — but it did.
"Clearly the removal of a large predator from the system has a trickle-down effect," said marine ecologist John Ogden of the University of South Florida.